| Reading method | The card is swiped or inserted into a slot, stripe facing the read head: contact is mandatory. | Radio exchange at 13.56 MHz (ISO/IEC 14443, NFC-compatible): the card is read a few centimetres away, without taking it out of a pocket. |
| Ease of use | A precise gesture to repeat at every opening: right way round, right side up, pushed all the way in. A guest in a hurry will try three times in the corridor. | No gesture to learn, no orientation to get right: present the card, the door opens. A clear gain for families and guests loaded with luggage. |
| Wear on the card | The stripe wears out with repeated insertions: scratches, delamination, grime (sand, sun cream, poolside). Sooner or later the card has to be re-encoded or replaced. | No friction. The weak point lies elsewhere: a card that is bent, punched or put through the wash breaks the antenna. Treated properly, it outlasts a stripe. |
| Demagnetisation | The stripe is wiped by contact with a magnet, a speaker, a magnetic tablet case or a phone. It is the number one failure at the front desk, hence the value of a HiCo stripe (approx. 2,750 Oe) rather than LoCo (approx. 300 Oe). | Immune to magnetic fields. The only limits: a metal mass pressed against the card, or a stack of cards that confuses the read. No data is lost. |
| Security | Data stored in the clear on the stripe (room number, dates). Copying it is within reach of anyone with a reader-encoder costing a few tens of euros. The only real protection: cryptography on the lock side and property-specific keys. | Encryption depends on the chip: CRYPTO1 for MIFARE Classic (broken), AES for DESFire EV2/EV3. Beware of installations that do nothing more than read the UID, which can be cloned with an NFC smartphone. |
| Compatibility | The de facto standard for forty years: virtually every lock, encoder and PMS accepts it. The safe choice for an older estate. | Several chip types (MIFARE Classic 1K/4K, DESFire, NFC): frequency and protocol need checking. A batch of "RFID" cards will not necessarily talk to your locks. Test card + encoder + lock together before ordering. |
| Total cost | One of the cheapest cards on the market (around €0.50 to €1.50 each in volume). Hidden cost: frequent replacements and time spent at reception. | A more expensive card (often €2 to €5 depending on the chip). Fewer replacements, fewer maintenance calls: the maths runs over three to five years, not on the unit price of the blank. |
| Card reuse and recycling | Re-encodable hundreds of times as long as the stripe holds up. At end of life, PVC plus a composite stripe: no common recycling stream, so it goes to general waste. | Also re-encodable, with a chip that is virtually indestructible. Recycling is trickier, as the copper or aluminium antenna is embedded in the PVC. Versions in recycled PET, wood or bamboo do exist. |
| Battery life and maintenance | Battery-powered lock (four AA, one to two years) or mains-powered. Simple electronics, but the read head gets dirty: clean with isopropyl alcohol and keep an eye on the mechanical parts. | Higher standby consumption, as the reader polls continuously: batteries to change more often, unless the lock is mains-powered or energy-harvesting. Remote diagnostics and updates are possible. |
| Handling a lost card | In standalone mode, the lost card stays valid until it expires or until a cancellation card is presented to the lock. On a networked system, invalidation propagates within minutes. | Same logic, but recent systems are more often natively networked: near-instant revocation, an audit trail of entries and key rotation without visiting every door. |
| Card customisation | Four-colour printing, lamination, foiling, numbering. The magnetic stripe takes a band out of the printable area and imposes a reading orientation on the design. | The chip is invisible: printing is possible across the whole card. Avoid metallic inks and thick varnishes over the antenna, as they reduce range. Short runs are feasible with a desktop encoder. |
| Upgrade path to mobile keys | A technical dead end: moving to smartphones means changing locks, cards and encoder. | A 13.56 MHz lock is already the building block for NFC and Bluetooth. With a compatible model, the same door accepts a card, a phone and a smartwatch: it is the stepping stone to the mobile key. |